I am a huge Harry Potter nerd, and I just got back from watching Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part 2 for the second time. I wanted to hold off on writing my review until I saw the film for a second time. I wanted to let what happened settle in, give myself some time to think about the book, and really see if my feelings held true after a second viewing. While I thought the book by JK Rowling was a perfect end to the series, I think this movie was the perfect and most satisfying film to end the film franchise.
I found the book a little boring and long around the middle, especially during the portion entitled Harry Potter and the long camping trip. When I went into Deathly Hallows Part 1, I was expecting a pretty slow and not so exciting film. While I really liked part 1, it definitely had that frustrating we don’t know what we are doing feel. I was also not sure how I felt about ending the first film right before the battle of Hogwarts, as it did not feel like a full film could be made out of that segment. Well, I was definitely wrong in that respect, the films were split at the perfect location, and the final film was an exciting rush to the end. If you have never read the book, then why are you here, and if you don’t want to be spoiled, turn back now!
I liked how the movie started; we got a short recap of Voldemort stealing Dumbledore’s wand and then we were right into the rest of the story. Gringotts was just as I had expected, and even better. I really enjoyed the scene with the dragon tied up and all white from being out of the sun. Not how I imagined it, but so perfect for the things happening there. Very quickly after that moment we were off to Hogwarts and the battle was primed and ready to go.
I think it’s very important in this moment to discuss how the canvas we paint a book and a movie on are very different. A book is personal to the reader, we read it by ourselves, and the world created is only limited by our imagination. In a book there is a longer time to add more details, and the action can be even bigger. To make a movie successful there needs to be bigger and grander action, but the amount of time, details, and world need to be a bit more limited. A movie needs to succeed in different levels on a screen, where we watch together. In a book we can create a world; in a movie we are presented a finite experience. If you go into this film with this perspective, you will really enjoy it.
As a whole I loved the film, but there were several things that blew me away. The first one was Helena Bonham Carter who played Bellatrix Lestrange. The scene where she was playing Hermione playing her character was just perfect. Carter did an amazing job embodying another character playing inside of her character, something I imagine to be very difficult to accomplish. Also being the number two bad guy in Voldemort’s gang, we got to see a lot of Bellatrix in the periphery being her usual awesome self. One of my favorite scenes in the book played out perfectly on screen, and that is when Mrs. Weasley killed Bellatrix, it was just right and got a round of applause both times I was in the theater!
One of my favorite characters in the book series was Professor McGonagall, and I loved how she got played up in this film. She had all the best lines from, “Potter, it’s good to see you,” to “I always wanted to use that spell.” She also had a great duel with Snape, showing her triumphant ascension to the headmastership! Speaking of characters, it was fun to see all of the characters from Harry’s world come back to the screen, just as in the book. I especially loved seeing all of these characters who we haven’t seen for several films. My top choice was Miriam Margolyes who played Professor Sprout in the second film, I was always so sad she was not in the subsequent films, it was so great to see her back on the screen.
In the relationships department I think all of the love played out really well. We got a big kiss between Ron and Hermione, and we saw their love grow over the film and play out perfectly in the end. I enjoyed the brief Harry Ginny embrace in the middle of the battle. A brief moment to show their love, just right as Harry was off to end the fight. The other prefect moment happened immediately after Neville killed Nagini the snake, which was the last horocrux. Harry and Voldemort looked at each other for just the right amount of time to acknowledge the moment had come, he was vulnerable, and then the fight ignited!
In the end there were a few things I was unhappy with, and they all came very close to the end. In the final battle, I was sad Harry and Voldemort’s fight didn’t play out in front of everyone. Outside of Hogwarts was much more of an epic location than the Great Hall, but it should have happened in everyone’s view. I also was sad in how Voldemort’s death eventually happened. In the book they had a battle and Voldemort shouted the killing curse and Harry shouted the blocking spell, in that moment the rebound is what killed Voldemort. On screen, I inferred those things happened in their characters minds instead of being said, and the death was not as dramatic as I wanted.
That leads in to the second thing I was sad about. Once Voldemort died, we had these really great moments where everyone had a celebration, and then Harry went up to Dumbeldore’s office repaired his wand and left the elder wand behind. We have been watching these movies for 10 years, and reading the books for even longer. I wanted the death to be more dramatic, and the moment after the battle to be more euphoric. I could have sat and watched that scene for a bit longer. But then we got the Harry, Ron, Hermione ending scene and the epilogue, which were just a beautiful and simple ending.
Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows was just about perfect. All of the elements were there, and as a huge fan of the series, I felt very satisfied in the end. Even though the characters were facing an epic battle, we had some laughter, we had a classic Ron moment when the trio arrives at Hogwarts and Ginny only runs to Harry. Then we got the best action sequences in the Potter series. The war was epic and even better then I pictured it. We saw a battle on screen, dead bodies and all. This epic 7 year journey to vanquish the dark lord was complete, and it left me wanting more but satisfied in everything I had just watched. (4 ½ stars out of 5)










